Last updated:
Main set page: D381 Overview & Gallery.
This is the only complete and correct D381 checklist; others found across the internet are just copies of lists from the 70’s and earlier that omit most variations as well as the Johnson card, and make no mention of Ferguson-only cards. I’ve combined the 100 known Fleischmann cards with the 4 cards issued only by Ferguson and added all known variations for Fleischmann cards, with descriptions.
One helpful thing about the old checklists, e.g., in The Sports Collectors Bible, is that someone (Larry Fritsch, perhaps?) provided information that certain cards exist that we have not been able to verify ourselves. Those checklists note variations for Becker, Clarke, Collins, and Thomas, all of which have been verified and are included below. They also claim that there are error cards for Keating and Kocher, as well as Konetchy and Knetzer, where the player photos are reversed; these are almost certainly differences between Fleischmann and Ferguson cards. We know that the Konetchy and Knetzer photos are wrong on Fleischmann cards, but correct with Ferguson cards. I haven’t seen the Keating and Kocher errors, but I’d guess it’s the reverse situation, i.e., the Fleischmann cards are correct and the Ferguson cards are wrong. Lastly, the old checklists note that a Jennings card exists. I have not been able to find a collector who has one or has an image. The hunt continues…
I’ve also made the checklist publicly available as a Google spreadsheet. The bottom of this page has lists for D381’s by team and the D381’s in the Burdick Collection at The Met. Sort any column by clicking on the text in the column header.
| Player | Team | Fleischmann card variations? | Fleischmann I (540 East 81st St. address) | Fleischmann II (Bronx Boul. & Post St. address) | Ferguson | Goodwin 2016 (coupons) | REA 2016 (coupons) | REA 2017 (no coupons) | REA 2020 (no coupons) | Picture Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adams | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | N | Action | ||
| Alexander, G. | Philadelphia NL | N | known | N | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Alexander, W. | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | N | N | Action | ||
| Allen | Boston NL | N | known | N | N | N | Y | Portrait | ||
| Anderson | New York NL | N | known | Y | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Bancroft | Philadelphia NL | N | known; position is "Short Stop" (Fleischmann is "Shortstop") | N | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Barry | Boston AL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Becker | Philadelphia NL | Y | Uniform logo not visible | Top of uniform logo visible | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Burns, E. | Philadelphia NL | Y | Uniform logo not visible | Top of uniform logo visible | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Burns, G. | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Byrne | Philadelphia NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Action | ||
| Caldwell | New York AL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Callahan | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Carrigan | Boston AL | N | possible (cited in SGC pop report) | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Cheney | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | N | Y | Portrait | ||
| Clark | Cincinnati NL | Y | Neither hand appears. No copyright on photo. | Photo extends below waist with right hand prominently shown. Copyright on photo. | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Cobb | Detroit AL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Collins | Boston AL | Y | One button is visible | No buttons are visible | unknown | Y | N | Y | N | Portrait |
| Coombs | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | N | N | N | N | Portrait | ||
| Cooper | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | N | Action | ||
| Cutshaw | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Daubert | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Dell | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Donovan | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Action | ||
| Doyle | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Egan | Boston NL | N | known | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Evers | Boston NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Fisher | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Gardner | Boston AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Gedeon | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Action | ||
| Gilbert | Boston NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Gilhooley | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | N | Y | Portrait | ||
| Gowdy | Boston NL | N | known | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Gregg | Boston AL | N | known (in Burdick collection) | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Griffith | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Groh | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Harmon | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Hartzell | New York AL | Y | Last name is spelled correctly. | Last name is misspelled as "Hartell". | known | Y | Y | Y | Y | Action |
| Hendriksen | Boston AL | N | known | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Hendrix | Chicago NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Herzog | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| High | New York AL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Hoblitzell | Boston AL | N | known; position is "1st Base" (Fleischmann is "First Base") | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Hunter | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Janvrin | Boston AL | Y | known | N | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Jennings | Detroit AL | N | [does not exist] | [does not exist] | unknown as yet, would be Ferguson only | N | N | N | N | ??? |
| Johnson | Washington AL | N | [does not exist] | [does not exist] | known, Ferguson only | N | N | N | N | Action |
| Johnston | Brooklyn NL | Y | 1-line caption | 2-line caption | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Kantlehner | Pittsburgh NL | Y | name spelled as "Kantlehuer" | name spelled as "Kantlehner" | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Action |
| Kauff | New York NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Keating | New York AL | N | unknown, but suspected to exist | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Killifer [Killefer] | Cincinnati NL | N | known; name spelled correctly | N | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Knetzer | Cincinnati NL | N (photos are wrong, but no variation) | Picture erroneously shows Konetchy (not a variation) | Picture erroneously shows Konetchy (not a variation) | known; picture is correct (Knetzer) | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Kocher | New York NL | N | unknown, but suspected to exist | Y | Y | N | N | Portrait | ||
| Konetchy | Boston NL | N (photos are wrong, but no variation) | Picture erroneously shows Knetzer in Brooklyn uniform. Lists position as "First Base". (not a variation) | Picture erroneously shows Knetzer in Brooklyn uniform. Lists position as "First Base". (not a variation) | known; picture correctly shows Konetchy and lists position as "1st Base". | Y | N | N | Y | Portrait (Ferguson is action) |
| Landerus [Luderus] | Philadelphia NL | Y | Uniform logo not visible. Name misspelled as "Landerus" | Part of uniform logo is visible. Name misspelled as "Landerus" | known; name misspelled differently as "Lauderus" | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Leonard | Boston AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Lewis | Boston AL | Y | 2nd uniform button is partially visible, copyright is flush with bottom | Space visible below 2nd button. Copyright is higher on left side. | known; position is "Left Field" (both Fleischmann variations wrongly list "Second Base"). | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Love | New York AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Mamaux | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Maranville | Boston NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Marquard | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Mathewson | New York NL | N | known | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| McKechnie | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Meyer [Meyers] | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Miller | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | N | Y | N | N | Portrait | ||
| Mollwitz | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Moran | Boston NL | N | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Mowrey | Brooklyn NL | Y | 1-line caption with position as "3rd Baseman". | 2-line caption with position as "3rd Base". | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Murphy | Philadelphia AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Nehf | Boston NL | N | [does not exist] | [does not exist] | known, Ferguson only | N | N | N | N | Portrait |
| O'Mara | Brooklyn NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Oldring | Philadelphia AL | Y | © is on same line with "Underwood & Underwood". Copyright is just above bottom border. | © is above "Underwood & Underwood". Copyright is higher up on left side. | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Paskert | Philadelphia NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Ragan | Boston NL | N | known | N | Y | Y | N | Action | ||
| Rariden | New York NL | Y | 2-line caption | 1-line caption or 2-line caption (variations exist from same location) | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Robertson | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Rodgers | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Rousch [Roush] | New York NL | Y | Position is "Right Field" | Position is "Right Fielder" | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Rucker | Brooklyn NL | Y | Uniform logo is not visible | Top of uniform logo is visible | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Rudolph | Boston NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Schang | Philadelphia AL | Y | 1 button visible. Copyright is small and close to bottom border. | 2 buttons visible. Copyright is easily legible and higher up. | unknown | N | N | Y | N | Portrait |
| Schauer | New York NL | Y | © in copyright is much larger than "Underwood & Underwood" | © in copyright is barely larger than "Underwood & Underwood" | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Schneider | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Schupp | New York NL | N | known | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Shore | Boston AL | N | unknown | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Smith | Boston NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Snodgrass | Boston NL | N | known; position is "Centerfield" (Fleischmann shows "Center Field") | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Speaker | Cleveland AL | Y | copyright is larger and extends to right side of uniform | copyright is small and covers only left side of uniform | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Stallings | Boston NL | N | unknown | Y | Y | N | Y | Portrait | ||
| Stengel | Brooklyn NL | Y | 1-line caption with last name misspelled as "Stengle" | 2-line caption with last name spelled correctly as "Stengel" | unknown | Y | Y | N | Y | Portrait |
| Stroud | New York NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Action | ||
| Strunk | Philadelphia AL | N | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Tesreau | New York NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Thomas | Boston AL | Y | 1 uniform button visible. | 2 uniform buttons visible. | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Toney | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Tragesser | Boston NL | N | [does not exist] | [does not exist] | known, Ferguson only | N | N | N | N | Portrait |
| Wagner | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Weilman | St. Louis AL | Y | Top of team name visible; © in copyright is white and is above "Underwood & Underwood" | Team name not visible; copyright is on one line | unknown | Y | N | Y | Y | Portrait |
| Wheat | Brooklyn NL | Y | Uniform logo not visible | Top of uniform logo visible | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
| Whitted | Philadelphia NL | N | unknown | Y | N | Y | N | Portrait | ||
| Wilson | Pittsburgh NL | N | unknown | N | N | Y | N | Action | ||
| Wingo | Cincinnati NL | N | unknown | N | Y | Y | Y | Portrait | ||
| Wood | Boston AL | Y | © is on same line as "Underwood & Underwood" | © in copyright line is above "Underwood & Underwood" (2 variations exist from this location) | known | Y | Y | Y | N | Portrait |
D381’s by Team
For the sake of completeness, this list includes the teams with zero players represented.
| Team | League | Count | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boston | AL | 13 | |
| Chicago | AL | 0 | |
| Cleveland | AL | 1 | |
| Detroit | AL | 2 | includes Jennings (Ferguson only) |
| New York | AL | 10 | |
| Philadelphia | AL | 4 | |
| St. Louis | AL | 1 | |
| Washington | AL | 1 | includes Johnson (Ferguson only) |
| Boston | NL | 15 | includes Nehf and Tragesser (Ferguson only) |
| Brooklyn | NL | 13 | |
| Chicago | NL | 1 | |
| Cincinnati | NL | 11 | |
| New York | NL | 16 | |
| Philadelphia | NL | 8 | |
| Pittsburgh | NL | 8 | |
| St. Louis | NL | 0 |
D381’s in Burdick Collection at The Met
These cards all have their coupons attached.
| Player | Bakery |
|---|---|
| Kantlehner | Fleischmann |
| Hendrix | Fleischmann |
| Mamaux | Fleischmann |
| Herzog | Fleischmann |
| Harmon | Fleischmann |
| Schauer | Fleischmann |
| Love | Fleischmann |
| Wheat | Fleischmann |
| Cooper | Fleischmann |
| Whitted | Fleischmann |
| Evers | Fleischmann |
| Weilman | Fleischmann |
| Bancroft | Fleischmann |
| Gregg | Ferguson |